My blog, USMedEdu — "U.S. Medical Education" — had lived on mitbbs.com since 2006, under the username dok_knife. Over the years it had accumulated more than 4,300 posts: study guides for Steps 1, 2, and 3 and the Step 2 CS exam, advice on residency applications and interviews, and notes on the working life of residents and fellows. With 43 million page views it was, for a generation of Chinese medical graduates (CMGs) dreaming of practicing medicine in America, a lighthouse of sorts – an encyclopedia of the Match.
In early 2021, a year into the pandemic, I found my blog was gone.
The site went down, and everything vanished overnight, like ash. Forty-three hundred posts – just GONE into cyberspace.
For years, I mourned it the way you mourn a burned library – until AI provided an opportunity for resurrection. I put my Muse AI agent on the Wayback Machine. Bit by bit, snapshot by snapshot, the AI agent began pulling the posts back from the internet archive. A resurrection in slow motion.
When most of those treasured articles had been pulled back from the vast cyberspace, I was so excited that tears welled up in my eyes. But as the posts came back, something else came back with them: the people – those vivid figures and touching stories.
# 1. The girl who squeezed into the van
Dr. MJ was my junior by more than a dozen classes – young enough to call me 师叔 (grand-uncle) in school rank. He knew the road to becoming a doctor in America existed, but in Canada, where he resided, the road was nearly closed: a dozen or so medical schools for 30 million people, residency spots filled almost entirely by domestic graduates. For a foreign graduate, the odds were brutal and dismal.
He had passed the USMLEs but had no idea how to walk the rest of the road. Then he found my blog – the posts, the Q&A threads – and heard I was holding a 老刀会 – "Old Knife" workshop, named after my own nickname on the forum. For a $10 registration fee, which included two meals and drinks, I offered free, in-person coaching at my house to CMGs applying to U.S. residencies. Dr. MJ decided this was his only chance to become un-lost, and talked a few like-minded friends into going with him.
They rented a van. Seven people set out from Toronto: the driver, who wasn't in medicine; the driver's wife, who wanted to become a doctor; Dr. MJ; and four others. At the last minute, the driver's 12- or 13-year-old daughter insisted on coming along. She wanted to see America, to sit in on the lectures, and – as she admitted later – to see "old Knifer's" big mansion.
So, the young girl squeezed in. Eight souls set out in a rented van for an eight-plus hours' drive from Toronto to Columbus, Ohio. They attended the workshop. That same night, after the workshop, they drove all the way back. It was grueling.
Of the six with aspirations to become doctors, one – who worked at a pharmaceutical company – eventually gave up the path. The other five all matched into US residencies. Dr. MJ matched into internal medicine the following year. He stayed in America and, today, practices in Seattle – an internist and hospitalist with his own clinic, living, by all accounts, a happy life.
The driver's wife matched into pediatrics. After residency, she went back to Canada and practices there as a pediatrician.
And the little girl who squeezed into the van to see the sights? She grew up, entered a Canadian medical school, matched into radiology, and is now a radiologist – the little girl who came to gawk at a big house, grown into an accomplished young physician.
Two generations of doctors, connected by one van.
# 2. The homework I tore up
Dr. C is a surgical pathology director at a State University Program, and the first extern I ever mentored. He lived a hundred-plus miles from Columbus, doing postdoctoral research at the University of Cincinnati. He wanted to become a doctor in America – specifically, he wanted pathology.
He contacted me, came to OSU, and spent six weeks shadowing me on service: driving back to Cincinnati on weekends, crashing at a friend's place on weeknights, rounding with me every day.
I was hard on him. Very hard. Just as my mentor was hard on me when I was a surgical pathology fellow at WUSL.
One day we had two superb lung cancer cases in NSCLC and small cell lung cancer. I took Dr C. and a young woman, who was also aiming for pathology, to the microscope, walked them through classification, diagnosis, differential, molecular essentials, prognosis and treatment, and gave them homework: read the lung cancer chapter overnight and write it up as a case report or summary. Due tomorrow.
The next day, both handed in their work. Hers was a crisp Excel table: tumor classification, clinical presentation, gross, microscopic, and X-ray findings, diagnostic pearls – neat columns, everything in its place. His was a hand-drawn table, one page, rough and slapdash, the handwriting crooked.
I held his page up next to hers. "Look at what your classmate did. Yours is a fail – not even close," I said, as I tore his homework in half, in front of everyone, and told him to redo it. He stood there humiliated, his face flushing red.
Dr. C went home and produced a proper table and case summary. From that day on, he was a different student. He had seen, in one torn page, exactly what his deficit was.
He did well on the rotation. Once, at grand rounds, an out-of-town speaker gave a talk on diabetes – very basic stuff, and a room full of anatomic pathologists sat in chilly silence. When Q&A came, nobody moved. Dr. C stood up and asked an excellent question, close to his own research. The speaker lit up and talked for another good while, breaking the ice. Afterward the program director came down and asked me, "Your extern asked such a high-quality question. What does he want to do?" I told him: a postdoc at Cincinnati who wants a pathology residency. "Good," the director said. "We'll support him."
During his rotation, I held the first-ever 老刀会 at my home. Dr. C ran around helping with everything. The meeting ran till ten at night; he was the last to leave, and only then drove back to Cincinnati.
When it came time to apply, he had only finished Step 1 and was still studying for Step 2. He hesitated – should he wait a year? I told him: don't waste the year, apply now. If a program director asks, tell them Step 2 is scheduled and in progress. To everyone's surprise, interviews poured in. Then came the impossible: pre-match offers from both the University of Chicago and Johns Hopkins.
The Chicago chair, Dr. Kumar – author of Robbins Pathologic Basis of Disease – had missed his first interview and specially invited him back for a second. After the second interview came the pre-match. He called me, torn: Chicago was my alma mater, a top-ten program he admired – but Hopkins was Hopkins.
I said, "Congratulations, and there's nothing to agonize over. Chicago is top ten. Hopkins is number one." He went to Hopkins, finished residency there, then completed his fellowship.
After training, he joined a large private group on excellent pay. But his wife had finished her internal medicine residency at Penn State in Hershey and didn't want to leave her home. So he went back to Hershey with her. Today he is a surgical pathology director – an outstanding pathologist, a familiar moderator at Chinese pathology conferences at home and abroad, and more important, in my view, very generous and supportive with the next generation of students.
What moves me most happened long before all that. Back in 2006–08, on the mitbbs.com medicine career forum, when some people were attacking me for no good reason, Dr. C stood up and wrote this: "Many people help others once or twice in their life at most. Only Dr. He pours his whole heart and soul into it – he treats this as his life's work."
Twenty years later, his words read like testimony – a student bearing witness for time itself.
The blog is coming back, post by post. But a blog is only digital stuff – pixels, really. What it carried was people: a girl squeezed into a van who became a radiologist; a humiliated extern who became a state university program director; and five aspiring doctors from Toronto who made it – four in America, one back in Canada.
We set out to rescue the posts. What came back to life were the people who saw their dreams come true and built happy family lives.
That is the torch, lit by a little match from a pathologist, passed hand to hand for 20 years, and still burning.
I always remember these famous words: "Except a corn of wheat fall into the ground and die, it abideth alone: but if it die, it bringeth forth much fruit." (John 12:24)
